Shenango outscored the opposition 16-8 in the second half, but fell to Western Beaver 46-24.
In the third quarter, Shenango trailed 46-8, when quarterback Anthony Prestopine called his own number, going 55 yards for the score making it 46-16.
With the loss, the Wildcats fall to 2-2 on the season.
Shenango will hit the road Friday, September 30 to take on Rochester.