Neshannock outscored Shenango 15-4 in overtime to get the victory, 68-57.
Ernie Burkes led the way for the Lancers with 27 points. John Sansone added 17 points, while Anthony Van Eman and Tyler Haswell each chipped in 10 points.
The Wildcats were led by Brett Chieze with 24 points. Jordan O'Hara notched 14 on the night.
Neshannock improved to 5-5 on the season, while Shenango dropped to 7-4.